Thursday, September 29, 2022

Pasha Family Narrative Perspectives

    After reading through three different perspectives in Home fire, I think that Shamsie (the author) wanted the readers to approach the novel as both, at first, seeing the actions of each other the characters in a biased way (each of the characters different perspectives) and, after reading through multiple perspectives, as a way to realize that what we think of a person or the actions that they make as  relative to our own experiences. We essentially are not that other person and will hold on to our own views, which isn't necessarily wrong, but we have to come to understand that the way we see the world is not the same for other people, even those who we love most, and it is hardly ever the whole picture. As a reader, we got to see how each of the different character's actions [Isma, Eamonn, and Parvaiz]  impacted each other and how their own feelings towards each other came from different angles. Isma, was seeing the world through the eyes of when her family was being watched and was struggling after her Father left them, became a terrorist, and died. Isma had to become responsible and take care of her younger siblings while being old enough to remember how the world saw her in both her culture and identity. Part of the reason, I believe, she began to hate Parvaiz so much after he joined the terrorist group was because she was old enough to remember how that same choice her father made impacted their family, and could not understand how Parvaiz came to the actions that he did. After reading about Parvaiz's perspective we come to understand how he was slowly indoctrinated into following his father's path. It wasn't such a cold cut decision as Isma had made it seem.

    With only reading three different perspectives so far, I think that Shamsie decided to write these stories in this particular order because whenever each of the character's perspectives come up they play a specific role in the novel to progress the storyline forward. For instance, Isma, being the oldest and on her way to her new life is reflecting on her family and what had previously happened. Isma, being a guarded character, was able to get the readers attention and hook them because her details and explanations at times were so vague and showed little emotion that peaked the readers interest into wanting to figure out what exactly was going on. Then it moved on to Eamonn, who was introduced in Isma's perspective, and we get to see what exactly is going through his head as well as see how he fits into the Pasha family through an outsider lens and progresses Aneeka's character through another persons perspective. Parvaiz comes into the story where the readers are finally able to get a better understanding of who Parvaiz is and why he made the decisions that ultimately hurt his family. We get to understand Aneeka's actions more. As for Aneeka coming next, I believe that we will get to understand the bond that she shares with Parvaiz and understand the actions that she took to get her brother back. If I were to predict why it ended with Karamat I think we will finally be able to understand this family through the eyes of the authority and how these types of families come to to pass as well as being a sort of outsider to each of the other's characters since he doesn't exactly, so far, seem to be directly connected to the Pasha family. His perspective would be more of an outside eye, as well as how, other people, being the general population or world would see the Pasha family without the different perspectives that we got previously.

4 comments:

  1. Hey Monique! I totally agree with your idea about Shamsie using different character perspectives to reflect bias. Imperfect, biased narrators are powerful because they not only reveal information about the other characters, but also about their own prejudices. I also am especially excited to read the section Karamat's eyes like you said. He seems to be sort of an 'odd man out' in the Pasha family dynamic, and I am curious to find out what new insights he brings to the equation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Monique! I didn't think about all the characters' biases at first, but I completely agree! All the characters view each other differently and have their own ideas and judgments, which allows for slow reveal of certain details and relationships. I think it's a great observation that Karamat is the odd one out of all the other sections, so hopefully his section is interesting and reveals a lot about the Pasha family and Muslims in Britain!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Monique! I think you touch on a very important point in regards to why Isma feels so betrayed by Parvais. She actually has a memory of most of the difficult events in their lives, while Parvais does not. Even though Isma may seem uptight at times, she is only trying to spare Parvais the fate of their father.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wonderful post! Your observations are making me think that the first 4 sections get increasingly "inside" each successive character, giving us more of their inner life than we had of the previous one...

    ReplyDelete

Wk. 10: Pachinko Lessons

  After finishing Pachinko I think one of the main reasons that Min Jin Lee wrote this novel was both to expose people do Korean history and...